Like the title says.
Edgar, our six year old male cat, who has been neutered since the age of one, has been spraying items like purses or bags, and also emptying his entire bladder on our curtains.
He only does this on things near our windows, so we think he gets angry seeing neighbourhood strays.
He was a stray street cat at the beginning of his life, then lived in a vet clinic for a while before we adopted him.
He is currently taking amitriptyline (I think) to try to calm him down to not do this, but it’s starting again with the spring.
What else could we be trying?
Edgar
Edit: When the weather is nicer (like earlier this week, before we got dumped on by a classic Manitoba April Blizzard), Edgar begs to go outside.
He was an outdoor cat earlier in his life, and when summer comes around we let him outside on a line so he can’t leave our yard, but he’s adamant about going outside.
I feel like letting him out would solve this problem, but I’m not about to have an outdoor cat while living in a city.
The last thing I want is to see his body on the road while driving home from work some day.
But I’m also feeling like I’m doing wrong by him by forcing him to stay indoors.
Brief Answer:
Your diagnosis is highly accurate: Edgar’s spraying and full bladder elimination are classic stress-induced territorial reactions to seeing neighborhood stray cats outside your windows.
The spraying on bags and curtains is marking the perimeter of his territory and the points of intrusion (the windows).
His history as a former street cat and his strong desire to go outside compound this territorial frustration, making him highly sensitive to perceived threats from strays.
Since he is already on Amitriptyline, the solution is not more medication but a comprehensive, cost-effective environmental overhaul to manage the sight-based triggers and satisfy his strong need for outdoor simulation.
You must immediately block his visual access to the strays by applying opaque window film or simply keeping curtains drawn in the problem areas.
Simultaneously, create appealing vertical territory near those windows (cat trees or shelves) where he can safely observe without feeling threatened, and plug in a Feliway Classic Diffuser in the affected room to counteract the anxiety, saving you from constant cleaning and potential behavioral escalation.
Detailed Answer:
It is an extremely difficult position to manage a former outdoor cat’s powerful instincts in a safe, indoor city environment, and your dedication to his safety is commendable.
You are correct that allowing him unsupervised outdoor access is too risky, and feeling like you are doing him “wrong” is natural, but his safety must come first.
The spraying is his way of dealing with the frustration of seeing a threat (the strays) intrude on his territory without being able to defend it physically.
Since his spraying is primarily localized near windows, the intervention must be targeted at those visual triggers.
The fact that the behavior is persisting, and even increasing with the change in weather (spring, when strays become more active), despite him being on Amitriptyline (a tricyclic antidepressant often used to treat anxiety-driven marking), indicates that the medication alone cannot overcome the intensity of the environmental trigger.
The problem is a physical sight line, not just an internal chemical imbalance.
The solution requires a three-part environmental and behavioral approach:
First, Eliminate Visual Access.
This is the most crucial, immediate, and cost-effective step.
You must stop him from seeing the strays.
Apply opaque window film (available cheaply at hardware stores) to the lower half of the windows where the spraying occurs.
Alternatively, keep the curtains or blinds permanently closed to the point where he cannot see the outside.
This directly removes the trigger, which is far more effective than trying to manage the reaction.
Second, Enrich Vertical Space and Territory.
Because he has high territorial needs, you must create appealing indoor territory, particularly vertical space, near (but not directly in front of) the problem windows.
Install a tall, sturdy cat tree or shelves that allow him to be high up.
Being elevated is a key component of feline security and territorial confidence.
This low-cost enrichment satisfies his need to survey his domain without the stress of being attacked by the strays he sees.
If you allow him outdoor time on a line, continue to do so in a predictable schedule, as this safely satisfies some of his outdoor drive.
Third, Intensify Pheromone Support and Cleaning.
Continue to use a Feliway Classic Diffuser (which uses the feline facial pheromone that signals safety) plugged in near the main window he targets.
This provides a constant, calming counter-scent to the anxiety he feels.
You must also commit to cleaning the curtains, bags, and pool table legs (from your prior description) with a high-quality enzymatic cleaner immediately to completely eradicate every trace of urine and marking scent.
If the scent remains, it will pull him back to remark that spot.
A comprehensive resource like the Cat Spray Stop guide by Susan Westinghouse can help you structure this multi-faceted approach to address the complexity of his street-cat background and high territorial needs, providing a cost-effective, customized strategy to finally break the habit.
About The Author
