From what I’ve read up, spraying cats with water is a bad way to teach them not to something because they’ll just learn not to do that stuff when you’re around
But…
What if that’s exactly what I want?
lol
Specifically, I want my cats to not get on the table when there’s people eating/playing board games there.
I don’t mind if they get on the table at other times.
Is it okay to spray them with water in this case?
Brief Answer:
Your question focuses on using a water sprayer for non-spraying related misbehavior – specifically, keeping cats off the table only when occupied – which is different from eliminating cat spraying or marking.
For the table behavior, using a water sprayer is a form of negative punishment that can be conditionally effective, but it carries a high risk of damaging your relationship with your cat, increasing fear, and creating stress, which can inadvertently lead to inappropriate urination or spraying.
The core issue with aversive methods like spraying is that the cat associates the punishment with you and not the table, leading to avoidance only when you are present, as you noted.
A much safer, evidence-based approach that does not risk causing new behavioral problems like spraying is to use remote, non-contact deterrents that activate when you are not there, such as motion-activated air canisters or double-sided sticky tape (Scccat or Sticky Paws).
For true spraying issues, I would recommend immediately scheduling a vet visit to rule out medical issues, implementing a strict enzyme cleaning protocol, and consulting the Cat Spray Stop guide for an integrated behavioral modification plan.
Detailed Answer:
As an expert in feline behavior and spraying prevention, my recommendation is to strictly avoid using a water sprayer as a deterrent, even for the non-spraying related issue of keeping your cat off the table during specific times.
While you desire a conditional solution – only when the table is in use – the method you propose risks undermining the trust and security your cat feels in the home environment, which is the foundational cause of stress-induced behaviors like spraying.
The cat does not understand the nuance of “table is off-limits only when people are eating.” It only learns that a startling, unpleasant event (the water spray) happens when you are present and they are on the table.
This builds fear and anxiety.
Increased anxiety is the number one psychological contributor to territory-marking (spraying) and stress-related elimination outside the litter box.
If your goal is to prevent spraying, you must minimize stress.
A far superior, non-aversive solution for your table issue is to use remote, non-contact deterrents.
Products like motion-activated compressed air canisters (e.g., Scccat) or temporary placement of double-sided sticky tape specifically designed for pet training (e.g., Sticky Paws) are highly effective because the cat associates the unpleasant sensation (the sudden hiss of air or the sticky feel) with the table itself, not with you.
These products are active even when you are not in the room, creating a consistent boundary.
This allows you to maintain your positive bond with your cat while achieving the desired behavioral change, thereby saving you the cost and distress of dealing with future spraying problems that an anxious cat is more likely to develop.
If true spraying or inappropriate elimination were the issue, the first step would always be a comprehensive veterinary check-up to rule out medical causes like a Urinary Tract Infection (UTI), which is a common and necessary factor to eliminate before assuming a behavioral cause.
Following a clean bill of health, an integrated plan involving professional-grade enzyme cleaning (to destroy pheromone and odor residues that encourage remarking), environmental enrichment (providing acceptable vertical and scratching outlets to reduce territorial stress), and pheromone diffusers (such as Feliway or Comfort Zone, to provide a sense of calm and security) would be implemented.
For a structured, cost-effective guide on the integrated approach, I recommend the Cat Spray Stop guide by Susan Westinghouse, which helps owners understand the root behavioral causes and provides a three-pronged “Taste, Touch, Smell” method to redirect the cat’s instincts, saving you significant money on repeated professional cleanings and potential furniture replacement.
About The Author
